Roof evaluation
What to expect from a roof evaluation
Before anyone can tell you whether you need a repair or a new roof, someone has to look at it. Here's what a thorough evaluation covers, and what you can check yourself without a ladder.
On this page
What a roofing professional looks at
- Shingle condition across every slope: granule loss, curling, cracking, missing or lifted shingles.
- Flashing at chimneys, walls, skylights, valleys and plumbing vents.
- Pipe boots and vents — rubber collars crack with age and are a common leak source.
- The deck, by feel underfoot and from the attic: soft spots, sagging, or visible rot.
- The attic: ventilation, daylight where it shouldn't be, water staining, damp insulation, or mold.
- Edges and gutters: drip edge, fascia condition, and granules collecting in gutters.
- Layers: how many roofs are already on the house, which affects tear-off.
What you can check safely from the ground
Please don't climb onto your roof. Ladders and roofs cause serious injuries. From the yard, a window, or the attic, look for:
- Shingles that look curled, cupped, cracked, or missing (binoculars help).
- Dark granules collecting at the bottom of downspouts or in gutters.
- Uneven or wavy rooflines. If anything looks like it sags, have it looked at promptly.
- Water stains on ceilings or around the chimney inside.
- In the attic, with a flashlight: water stains on the underside of the deck, or daylight around pipes.
Photos of what you find are helpful. You can add them to an estimate request.
How the visit usually goes
Quick conversation
What you've noticed, how old the roof is, and what you're hoping to do.
Outside and up top
The roofer inspects the roof itself, often with photos of anything notable.
Attic look
Ventilation and the underside of the deck tell a lot about the roof's health.
Findings and next steps
A recommendation (repair, replace, or leave it) and, if relevant, an estimate.
What you should come away with
A clear explanation of what they found and why it matters, photos of problem areas, a recommendation, and, if you're considering replacement, a written estimate that spells out scope, materials, and how surprises like decking are priced.
If the recommendation is replacement, ask what would happen if you waited a year. An honest answer helps you plan, and our repair vs replacement guide can help you weigh it.
Roof evaluation questions
Is a roof evaluation free?
Requesting one through RoofReady is free. Many roofers don't charge for a replacement estimate, but policies vary. Confirm with the roofing professional when they contact you.
How long does an evaluation take?
It depends on the roof's size and access, but for most homes it's a single visit. Allow time to talk through findings.
Does RoofReady inspect roofs?
No. Evaluations are done by an independent local roofing professional. RoofReady connects you; it doesn't inspect or perform work.
Have your roof looked at
Tell us what you're noticing. An independent local roofing professional will reach out to schedule an evaluation.